Electrification is a central part of the transformation towards a more sustainable world. For public transport, it goes way beyond the local CO2 emissions. The dependencies on new technologies and new supply chains, come with a responsibility to assess the total life cycle impact on environment and people. For public procurement this requires conscious choices. How much should the less obvious factors of sustainability weigh in?
From a life-cycle perspective, a zero-emission vehicle is far from emission-free. Vehicle and battery manufacturing come with a carbon footprint, as does the energy used for the daily charging. To a large extent, the extraction and enrichment of new materials required for electric vehicles take place in operations with limited transparency. And this raises questions about resource depletion, pollution, working conditions and even human rights.
When a city transforms its transport system through electrification, these wider sustainability factors must also be taken into account. There is no global consensus on what sustainability is, and the competition between manufacturers is fierce.
In the quest for lower price and market shares, there is an obvious risk that countries with less developed legislation on working conditions and manufacturing standards allow manufacturers to ignore environmental and humanitarian aspects.
For a city, this means that a conflict may arise between affordability and sustainability. The challenge is to balance the goal of reducing local CO2 emissions and pollution at the lowest possible cost with broader sustainability commitments.
Purchasing lower-cost buses may accelerate electrification, but without a thorough assessment of life-cycle environmental and social impacts, a city may end up undermining its own sustainability objectives.
For public procurement, the differences pose delicate and somewhat uncomfortable questions:
So, how can Public Procurement contribute? The first step is to look beyond local CO2 emissions and define which sustainability criteria should shape procurement decisions. As cities electrify public transport, they also have an opportunity to set standards for transparency, life-cycle impact and responsible sourcing. In fact, writing the tenders can be seen as a declaration, a way to clearly show the city's perspective on sustainability.
Embracing the wider scope of sustainability requires mutual transparency between procurement bodies, transport authorities, operators and vehicle manufacturers. It also requires trust in the information exchanged, as well as in the suppliers’ long-term commitment to serving the city.
The transition to electric public transport is not just a technological shift. It’s also a test of our broader commitment to sustainability. Cities have a choice: to see electrification as a local carbon footprint reduction, or as an opportunity to embrace the wider spectrum of sustainability.
By demanding transparency, life-cycle perspective, and responsible sourcing into procurement decisions, stakeholders can ensure that progress is not only local, but meaningful globally. In doing so, cities will actively shape a transport system that is aligned with environmental commitments as well as long-term societal values.